Eye pencil ranking – the best eye pencils of 2024
Eye pencil is one of the makeup essentials. If you like the effect of optical eye enlargement or smokey eyes, a good eye pencil is essential. The right product will effectively emphasize the look and perform eye makeup. When choosing an eyeliner, it is worth paying attention to its pigmentation, which makes the colour expressive. Durability is an equally important factor, because none of us wants to be afraid of the "panda effect" during an evening out. Hardness is also important, which significantly affects the convenience of application. When creating the ranking of eye pencils, we took into account, among others these factors. Check out our ranking and choose the best eyeliner for your needs.
Ranking of eye pencils
Orphica, Arrow, black eyeliner with plant extracts and eraser
| Pigmentation | 10 |
| Durability | 9.9 |
| Price | 8.9 |
| Efficiency | 9.8 |
| No irritations | 9.9 |
| Hardness | 9.8 |
| Composition | 10 |
Editorial Text:
The Orphica Arrow eyeliner is perfect for making lines and highlighting the waterline, giving a great optical eye enlargement effect 🤩. Our testers paid attention to the very convenient application and high durability of the lines. The makeup made with Orphica Arrow is really durable and does not smudge 💪. The eyeliner is finished with a sponge for rubbing, so you can easily achieve the effect of smokey eyes. The pigmentation of the eyeliner is very intense, the black is deep and lasts for many hours. It is also worth emphasizing the composition of Arrow, because in addition to a great visual effect, the pencil also provides ingredients that support the skin around the eyes. Natural extracts of flax, calendula and calamus support skin regeneration and protect against irritation 🌿. The light formula with plant extracts has been dermatologically and ophthalmological tested – it does not cause irritation and is safe. The Orphica Arrow eye pencil is more than just a make-up product ✨. This is an excellent proposition that combines the effect of unique makeup and natural skin support, which is why it deservedly wins the ❤list ️.
Benefits
Orphica, Arrow, black eyeliner with plant extracts and eraser
- good pigmentation
- does not smudge
- does not sensitise
- contains natural extracts of flax, calamus & calendula
- high durability
- grinding sponge
- soft
- easy application
- dermatologically and ophthalmological tested
Disadvantages
Orphica, Arrow, black eyeliner with plant extracts and eraser
- only available in selected stores or the Nutridome app
- relatively high price
Maybelline New York, Tattoo Gel Liner, eyeliner
| Pigmentation | 8.5 |
| Durability | 8.4 |
| Price | 8.7 |
| Efficiency | 5 |
| No irritations | 8 |
| Hardness | 8.1 |
| Composition | 7.9 |
Editorial Text:
The next position in our ranking is the Tattoo Gel Liner from Maybelline. We focused on Deep Onyx, which is classic black. Thanks to the gel formula, the application is easy and, depending on your needs, you can get the effect of both a strong and a subtle line. The Tattoo Gel eye pencil is quite durable, although declarations about maintaining after 36 hours can be shelved alongside fairy tales 🤔. The colour is sufficiently intense and resistant to water. In the composition there are no substances that support the skin around the eyes. The biggest minus is the plastic shell of the eyeliner, which makes it difficult to properly temper and makes the pencil break and wastes the product. Maybelline Tattoo Gel Liner is a good eye pencil, but due to the above problems it could not take a higher position 🙂.
Benefits
Maybelline New York, Tattoo Gel Liner, eyeliner
- intense colour
- easy application
- good durability
- waterproof
Disadvantages
Maybelline New York, Tattoo Gel Liner, eyeliner
- plastic coating makes sharpening difficult
- the pencil is brittle, which wastes a lot
- no sponge
- no natural extracts
Rimmel, Exaggerate 262 Blackest Black, eyeliner
| Pigmentation | 8.3 |
| Durability | 7.3 |
| Price | 8.6 |
| Efficiency | 6.8 |
| No irritations | 8 |
| Hardness | 7.8 |
| Composition | 7 |
Editorial Text:
The well-known beauty brand Rimmel offers the popular Exaggerate eye pencil. We decided to take a closer look at it as part of testing for today's ranking. The Rimmel Exaggerate pencil spreads easily and allows you to precisely apply lines in your preferred shape 😊. The included sponge allows you to blend the colour and achieve the effect of smokey eyes. Durability is not the best, there are also cases of makeup particles falling off. Despite the manufacturer's declaration, the Exaggerate pencil is not very resistant to water. The composition is strongly chemical, does not contain ingredients that support the skin around the eyes. The pencil after opening hardens quite quickly, which over time becomes less convenient to use 😒.
Benefits
Rimmel, Exaggerate 262 Blackest Black, eyeliner
- intense blacks
- easy distribution
- grinding sponge
- dermatologically and ophthalmologically tested.
Disadvantages
Rimmel, Exaggerate 262 Blackest Black, eyeliner
- hardens when opened
- a lot of chemical ingredients in the composition
- average durability
- happens to fall off
- low water resistance despite the manufacturer's declaration
Max Factor, Kohl Pencil, eyeliner
| Pigmentation | 8.1 |
| Durability | 7.1 |
| Price | 8.8 |
| Efficiency | 7.5 |
| No irritations | 7.9 |
| Hardness | 6.6 |
| Composition | 7.4 |
Editorial Text:
Another tested proposal is the black eyeliner Kohl Pencil by Max Factor, specializing in make-up products. The product has an affordable price and the colour is well pigmented. Unfortunately, the pencil has several drawbacks. First of all, it is too hard, which makes its use not comfortable for everyone 🙄. Its durability is also not the best. Kohl Pencil tends to blur, causing precise lines to lose their clarity over time 😒. The composition does not contain any caring ingredients. Max Factor Kohl Pencil is a rather budget option for occasions when you do not need a lasting effect for a few hours.
Benefits
Max Factor, Kohl Pencil, eyeliner
- strongly pigmented
- allows you to get the effect of a cat's eye or smokey eyes
- price
Disadvantages
Max Factor, Kohl Pencil, eyeliner
- too hard
- inconvenient application
- quite often smears
- unsatisfactory durability
NYX Professional Makeup, Slim Eye Pencil, Eyeliner
| Pigmentation | 8 |
| Durability | 6 |
| Price | 9.5 |
| Efficiency | 7.6 |
| No irritations | 7.5 |
| Hardness | 6.5 |
| Composition | 7.7 |
Editorial Text:
NYX is a daughter brand of the well-known and popular L'Oréal Paris. NYX cosmetics is a budget line of products at a low price. This is the NYX Slim Eye Pencil. The product has the right pigmentation, black is expressive and effective. The advantage is efficiency, the pencil does not wear out quickly, but this is due to quite high hardness, which not everyone will like. The NYX eye pencil is not very durable 😞. Especially quickly disappears from the waterline. Paradoxically, it is quite difficult to clean it, one cleansing of the face with micellar liquid may not be enough. During regular promotions, the NYX Slim Eye Pencil can be found at a price below $10, so if you're looking for a budget eye pencil, then you might consider it. Although it is worth bearing in mind that in this case the quality corresponds to the price 💰.
Benefits
NYX Professional Makeup, Slim Eye Pencil, Eyeliner
- nice black
- high efficiency
- low price
Disadvantages
NYX Professional Makeup, Slim Eye Pencil, Eyeliner
- flows from the waterline
- difficult to wash off
- hardness
- poor durability
Author:
8404 votes
Add Comment
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *