Mascara ranking – the best mascaras of 2023

A good mascara is the basis of any make-up. Properly highlighted, thickened eyelashes are the key to achieving the effect of an expressive look and optical enlargement of the eyes. How to choose the best mascara? It is worth looking for products that will not have a heavy composition full of chemical substances. It is better to choose mascaras with the addition of natural substances, which, in addition to their visual effect, will have a positive effect on the condition of the hair. A good mascara should spread well, not stick to the eyelashes and not crumble or form clumps. We have taken these and other features into account and prepared a ranking of the best mascaras. See the top 5 and choose the best mascara!

Mascara ranking

XL UP Orphica volumising, curling and lengthening mascara

Lengthening of eyelashes 9.8
Thickening of eyelashes 9.9
Price 8.7
Efficiency 9.6
No irritation 9.9
Consistency 9.7
Composition 10
Average Rating: 4.83, 1373 votes

Editorial Text:

Orphica UP mascara was created to thicken and lengthen eyelashes. It fulfils this task perfectly ❤️. Our testers were delighted with the WOW effect. The deep black UP mascara covers perfectly after just one stroke and lasts for a long time. Thanks to the right consistency, it does not crumble during the day. An additional advantage are the natural ingredients contained in the formula, which additionally care for the eyelashes. Canadian rapeseed oil, shea butter and glycerin promote regeneration and protect against breakage 🌿. The included silicone brush is ergonomic and de-tangles the hair well, making the application simple and the lashes not sticky. The effect of optical lengthening and thickening of eyelashes is superb 💪. In addition, the mascara has been dermatologically and ophthalmologically tested, so it works well for sensitive eyes. All this makes the Orphica UP mascara a product that we can highly recommend ✨.

Benefits

XL UP Orphica volumising, curling and lengthening mascara

  • great thickening
  • visible thickening
  • optically lengthens the hair
  • contains natural ingredients
  • does not irritate
  • dermatologically and ophthalmologically tested
  • nourishes eyelashes
  • does not stick the eyelashes together
  • convenient application
  • efficient
  • large packaging capacity

Disadvantages

XL UP Orphica volumising, curling and lengthening mascara

  • available only in selected stores or the Nutridome app

L'Oreal Paris, Volume Million Lashes Extra Black, mascara

Lengthening of eyelashes 8.6
Thickening of eyelashes 8.7
Price 7.5
Efficiency 7.7
No irritation 7.9
Consistency 7.8
Composition 7.9
Average Rating: 4.01, 784 votes

Editorial Text:

Volume Million Lashes in the Extra Black version is a proposition of the L'Oreal Paris brand, which has been popular on the cosmetics market for years. The mascara, true to its name, has a deep black colour, the thickening effect is quite good, as well as the optical thickening of the eyelashes 🙂. The application is comfortable, thanks to the silicone brush, the hair comb well. The mascara's formula also contains oils that are supposed to additionally care for the eyelashes. Unfortunately, L'Oreal Extra Black requires a few strokes to get the desired results, and there are perhaps even too many oils, as our testers reported that they sometimes had sticky lashes 🤔.

Benefits

L'Oreal Paris, Volume Million Lashes Extra Black, mascara

  • good thickening and densifying effect
  • contains oils to care for the eyelashes
  • good shape of brush
  • large capacity

Disadvantages

L'Oreal Paris, Volume Million Lashes Extra Black, mascara

  • average price
  • requires a few strokes to get the right results
  • can glue eyelashes together
  • chipping happens during the day

Max Factor 2000 Calorie, mascara

Lengthening of eyelashes 8.4
Thickening of eyelashes 8.2
Price 7.2
Efficiency 6.1
No irritation 8
Consistency 7.8
Composition 7.9
Average Rating: 3.83, 490 votes

Editorial Text:

2000 Calorie is a mascara by Max Factor, founded by an entrepreneur of Polish descent. It is one of the world-famous brands in the make-up industry, which is why we could not leave it out of our ranking 😉. In practice, we can praise the 2000 Calorie mascara for its optical effect of increased volume and good pigmentation. The black of the mascara is well saturated and looks impressive on the eyes. A dense brush is comfortable to use, but it collects too much mascara, causing it to come into contact with the air. Unfortunately, this means that the mascara dries quickly after opening and in practice you have to use it quickly before it becomes useless 😒. The effects of Max Factor 2000 Calorie are good, the look becomes more expressive, but the mascara tends to fall off. As a mascara for shorter, special occasions, it will work well, but on a daily basis we recommend other options 😊.

Benefits

Max Factor 2000 Calorie, mascara

  • good volumising effect
  • good pigmentation
  • large packaging capacity
  • nice performance

Disadvantages

Max Factor 2000 Calorie, mascara

  • falls off during the day
  • average price
  • dries quickly when opened
  • brush takes on too much mascara
  • it stings the eyes

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara

Lengthening of eyelashes 8.2
Thickening of eyelashes 7.6
Price 7.5
Efficiency 7.5
No irritation 7.7
Consistency 7.6
Composition 5
Average Rating: 3.65, 327 votes

Editorial Text:

Maybelline is another world-famous mascara brand. To test in the ranking, we bet on Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High, which is very popular in our market. The lengthening the eyelashes is really effective, they gain length visually 💪. As for thickening it is a bit worse, with only a slight effect being noticeable. Our testers also praised the performance of the mascara, which lasted for a long time, despite the smaller volume of the packaging. The weak point of the Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High is the brush, which is small and too flexible, making the application uncomfortable and you can inadvertently stick the lashes together 🙄. The black of the mascara, on the other hand, is intense and pretty, but you have to be careful about contact with water. It's not a waterproof mascara, one tear is enough for it to start dissolving 🐼. It's not bad overall, but there are better mascaras available for the price. Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara is a product mainly for declared fans of the brand. To paraphrase the advertising slogan: maybe it's better to bet on what you’re born with and not on this particular Maybelline 🙃.

Benefits

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara

  • nice lengthening of eyelashes
  • slight thickening effect
  • intense color
  • nice performance

Disadvantages

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara

  • small packaging capacity
  • very sensitive to water
  • glues eyelashes together
  • brush is too soft
  • cases of eye irritation
  • very long, chemical composition

LANCÔME, Lash Idôle Mascara

Lengthening of eyelashes 8.1
Thickening of eyelashes 8
Price 3
Efficiency 8.1
No irritation 7.5
Consistency 7.6
Composition 7.9
Average Rating: 3.59, 229 votes

Editorial Text:

The French brand Lancome, in addition to well-known perfumes, also offers cosmetics and mascaras. We opted for the popular Lash Idole Mascara. It is available in two variants: 5 ml and 8 ml. In contrast to the items above, the Lancome mascara stands out for its good resistance to moisture. When using it, you can safely get emotional 😂. Our group of testers praised the brush, which is precise and has the right flexibility and size. The mascara itself has an intense black colour. The effect of lengthening and thickening eyelashes is good 💪. However, it is a high-end product and with such a high price, we expected a WOW effect. Meanwhile, Lancome Lash Idole Mascara doesn't really differ much from cheaper options, and some of them are much better. It's a good product, but at a totally exorbitant price 💰.

Benefits

LANCÔME, Lash Idôle Mascara

  • good, precise brush
  • good durability
  • tolerates moisture well
  • nice, intense black

Disadvantages

LANCÔME, Lash Idôle Mascara

  • no wow factor
  • very high price
  • can glue eyelashes together
  • effects disproportionate to the price

Author:

Author:  Emily Smith - Mascara ranking – the best mascaras of 2023 | Consumer-reports.ie

Emily Smith

Category: Cosmetics

Mascara ranking – the best mascaras of 2023 Mascara ranking – the best mascaras of 2023 Mascara ranking – the best mascaras of 2023 Mascara ranking – the best mascaras of 2023 Mascara ranking – the best mascaras of 2023
4.63

Average Rating: 4.63

4118 votes

Add Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *









Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.